Is the Physicality in the PWHL Too Much?

Lately I've noticed just how much physicality there is in the PWHL and I'm wondering if it's good.

The first season of the Professional Women’s Hockey League is nearing its end, and it’s been a fun ride. Something different about this league is that they allow body-checking, which is usually a no in women’s hockey and one of the biggest differences between men’s and women’s hockey. The rule states, “Body-checking is allowed when there is clear intention of playing the puck or attempting to “gain possession” of the puck except in the situation described in this rule.”

The rulebook states that players can simultaneously push each other within reason when going after the puck, and possession is the intention. It goes into greater detail, but the main idea is that they can use contact to get the puck. This has changed the game dramatically from what it used to be, and while initially I was against the idea, seeing it in person has made me think a little more about it.

As the postseason approaches, the intensity of the hits escalates, much like in the NHL. It has been a fascinating and enjoyable shift as the game takes on a new dynamic. However, I still maintain that there should be a clear line between what is permissible and what is not, lest the game become solely about physicality and forget the skill involved. Having grown up playing hockey and observing the differences between men’s and women’s hockey, getting used to the added physicality in the women’s game has taken some time.